Why Your SaaS Needs More Than a User Onboarding Checklist

Onboarding Checklist
February 28, 2024
Jamie McDermott
Checklists are useful — but they won’t fix activation. This post explains why outcome-based onboarding outperforms task-based flows in SaaS.

Checklists are helpful.
They keep your onboarding process organized.
They make sure you’re not forgetting any steps.
They help your team move fast.

But here’s the truth most SaaS teams learn too late:

✅ A checklist is not a strategy.

It won’t tell you what matters most.
It won’t adapt to different users.
And it won’t solve your activation problem on its own.

Here’s why — and what to do instead.

What is a user onboarding checklist?

A user onboarding checklist is a list of tasks or milestones designed to help new users complete setup and get started with your product.

Common examples:

  • Verify email address
  • Complete profile
  • Connect data source
  • Invite team
  • Launch first report

These are useful steps — but they’re often built around what your product can do, not what the user actually needs.

Where most checklists go wrong

🧩 They assume every user follows the same path
Your users don’t all have the same job title, goal, or experience. A rigid checklist treats them like they do.

⚙️ They focus on feature completion
You might be checking off tasks, but if those tasks don’t drive value, they’re noise.

⛔️ They create dead-ends
Many checklists get users part of the way, then leave them stuck — with no clear next action or reward.

What great onboarding does instead

Centers on outcomes, not tasks
Instead of asking “Did they upload their logo?” ask “Did they achieve something meaningful?”

Adapts based on context
Good onboarding adjusts to the user’s role, goal, or plan — even if it’s subtle.

Builds a value loop
It gets users doing something useful, then reinforces that behavior until it becomes sticky.

When should you use a checklist?

Checklists do have value when used intentionally:

  • As internal tools for your CS or onboarding team
  • As part of high-touch onboarding for complex use cases
  • As a light UI element only if tied to meaningful outcomes

But they should always support the bigger strategy — not replace it.

What to build instead: an onboarding blueprint

Here’s a lightweight framework we use with clients:

  1. Map the outcome – What’s the first win a new user needs to achieve?
  2. Work backward – What steps get them there with the least effort?
  3. Add structure – Group steps into guided flows, nudges, or UI elements
  4. Measure drop-off – Track where users stop progressing
  5. Refine often – Update flows based on behavior, not assumptions

Final takeaway

If your onboarding checklist isn’t working, it’s probably not because it’s incomplete.
It’s because your users don’t need steps — they need success.

Start with outcomes.
Then build the experience that gets users there — checklists included.